This article was published in The 30 Second Wine Advisor on Monday, Apr. 7, 2008 and can be found at http://www.wineloverspage.com/wineadvisor2/tswa20080407.php.
Primitivo or Zinfandel?
Is it Zinfandel, or is it Primitivo? Oddly, the Italian red wine we feature today is both, if its label is to be believed: The Italian Primitivo gets top billing, but the bottom of the label, in fair-size print, reads (in English), "From Old Vines Zinfandel."
What we have here is a case of grape science catching up with reality, while bureaucracy lags behind.
Zinfandel, long called a "mystery grape" because it seemed to appear from nowhere in California Gold Rush days, hyped by a promoter named Agoston Haraszthy, who claimed that he had brought the rare grape to California from his native Hungary. In fact, Haraszthy certainly exaggerated his role: Zinfandel (sometimes rendered "Zinfindal," "Zierfandler" or "Zeinfindall") was well-known in the Eastern U.S. as a table grape long before Haraszthy set foot in Napa. It had turned up in a horticultural fair in Massachusetts as early as 1834.
Also, based on similarity in the grape and its leaves and the wine it made, Zinfandel for many years was thought to be a sibling of the Southern Italian Primitivo of Puglia.
It was only as recently as 2001 that modern grape sleuths, including Dr. Carole Meredith of the University of California at Davis, used DNA technology to confirm that Zinfandel and Primitivo are the identical grape, albeit different clones; and the same is true of the little-known Crljenik Kasteljanski of Croatia, which is now thought to be the original variety, exported to Italy as Primitivo and to the U.S. as Zinfandel.
Based on this evidence, the European Union moved quickly to permit Italian producers to use either "Primitivo" or "Zinfandel" (or, as in the case of today's wine, both) to label wines made from either grape. The move makes great sense for Italy, as Zinfandel is immensely popular in the U.S. and more likely to sell wine exports than the relatively unfamiliar Primitivo.
U.S. regulators, on the other hand, have been slower to approve legal changes. The name Primitivo is now permitted for U.S. wineries (such as Rabbit Ridge) making wine from the Primitivo clone; but in contrast with European rules, American wineries may not use the names Primitivo and Zinfandel as synonyms. A proposal to allow this has been on the books since 2002 but has not been acted upon, reportedly because of opposition by Zinfandel producers who aren't excited about the possibility of competition.
Meanwhile, because the U.S. has signed off on the European labeling laws, this results in a curious situation in which European wineries may call Primitivo "Zinfandel" in U.S. sales, but American wineries may not.
Frankly, and probably more because of differences in wine-making styles than in fruit or terroir, I have rarely found Primitivo and Zinfandel all that similar. There's often a berry-like character in both, but differences typically fall acros the usual Old World-New World lines, with most Zins landing on the big fruit, high-alcohol side, while Primitivo tends to lower alcohol and hints of earth, plus a whack of oak if the producer wants to impress the critics.
Attention Red Wine Lovers! Something new from The California Wine Club
The California Wine Club now offers Two Bottle Red-Only shipments from their upper level club, Signature Series.
Each shipment includes two different bottles of highly-rated and coveted California wine. Two bottle deliveries average $125 and you may choose to receive shipments monthly, every other month or quarterly. In addition each shipment includes detailed tasting notes, winemaker comments and insight to what makes the wines so special.
If you would like to try this new Signature Series option, please visit www.cawineclub.com, click on Become a Member and choose the Signature Series Two Bottle option from the drop down menu.
Use promo code: Advisor and receive your first month at half off!
Villa Brondello 2005 Primitivo Puglia "From Old Vines Zinfandel" ($11)
Inky blackish-purple with a thin violet edge. Aromas reminiscent of Zinfandel but throttled back, black raspberries and a more winey hint of Chambord raspberry liqueur with a faint earthy back note. Black fruit flavor held up with crisp acidity and marked tannins; 13 percent alcohol makes it relatively lightweight compared with its New World cousins, but I like it the better for that. U.S. importer: Scoperta Importing Co. Inc., Cleveland Heights, Ohio. (April 5, 2008)
FOOD MATCH: A natural with a simple dinner of spaghetti and meatballs.
VALUE: Hard to beat at just over $10 in today's economy.
WHEN TO DRINK: The good combination of fruit, acidity and tannins suggests at least modest aging potential, but it's really meant to drink up, particularly since the track record for synthetic corks in cellaring remains doubtful.
FIND THIS WINE ONLINE:
U.S. readers may be able to get more information about local distributors from the importing company, Scoperta, in Cleveland Heights, Ohio.
Talk About Wine Online
If you have questions, comments or ideas to share about today's article
Everyone is free to browse. If you'd like to post a comment, question or reply, you must register, but registration is free and easy. Do take care to register using your real name, or as a minimum, your real first name and last initial. Anonymous registrations are quietly discarded.
To contact me by E-mail, write firstname.lastname@example.org. I'll respond personally to the extent that time and volume permit.
PRINT OUT TODAY'S ARTICLE
Last Week's Wine Advisor Index
The Wine Advisor's daily edition is usually distributed on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays (and, for those who subscribe, the FoodLetter on Thursdays). Here's the index to last week's columns:
A sweet kiss (April 4, 2008)
Wine Focus - Loire Chenin Blanc (April 2, 2008)
Cooked! (March 31, 2008)
Complete 30 Second Wine Advisor archive:
Wine Advisor FoodLetter: Quick jambalaya (April 3, 2008)
Wine Advisor Foodletter archive: