Oak or noak?
Over the years, I've developed a bit of a knee-jerk negative response to the presence of perceptible oak in wine.
For a long time, this was a rational position, as way too many producers - particularly through the 1980s and 1990s - seemed to joyously over-oak every wine in sight, resulting in oceans of wine that reeked of raw wood, to the extent that pouring a glass of one created a sensation similar to that of walking into a house with freshly sanded floors.
But times and customs change, and it seems to me that - with a few notable exceptions - a certain order has returned to the wine universe as the pendulum swings back toward the center. Exposure to a lot of California "Rhone-style" wines at the recent MoCool tasting in Michigan reinforced my impression that there's plenty of complex, balanced wine coming from the Golden State that even a dyed-in-the-wool Europhile can love.
And speaking of that, even the most ardent oak-phobe has to acknowledge the ongoing presence of barrel rooms in the cellars beneath just about every European winery. From great Bordeaux to White Burgundy, many of Europe's greatest wine treasures wouldn't be the same without a kiss of oak. And from Italy's grand Riservas to the oak-nurtured Crianzas of Rioja, many of the European classics require oak, by custom and by law.
In short, the problem with oak has never been its use but its abuse. As I've said before, the Boston-area wine retailer Richard Eccleston captured the concept beautifully in the pithy one-liner, "Oak should be a spice, not a sauce."
Today's tasting offers a glimpse into the effect of oak on wine: I set up a "blind" tasting that pitted a white Burgundy from Saint-Aubin, produced by Michel Colin-Deléger, a maker with a reputation for a rather heavy hand with oak (at least by European standards), against a New Zelaand Chardonnay from Kim Crawford, a Marlborough producer who makes a virtue out of shunning oak entirely.
As it turned out, the test needn't have been done "blind." The spicy signature of oak and the richer golden color of the Deléger made it a no-brainer to distinguish it from the nothing-but-fruit Kim Crawford, even in plain, unmarked glasses.
But here's the interesting bit: Although I might have rated the Crawford well in isolation because of its crisp, pure fruit flavors, in a side-by-side comparison the relatively oaky French wine dominated the competition on the basis of aroma and flavor interest, richness and complexity. The New Zealand contender was a nice, fruity, refreshing quaff, but in that instinctive, subjective judgement process that leads you unerringly back to one particular bottle when it's time for a refill, the French wine was the easy winner.
So much for oak-phobia.
TALK ABOUT WINE ONLINE
If you prefer to comment privately, feel free to send me E-mail at email@example.com. I'll respond personally to the extent that time and volume permit.
PRINT OUT TODAY'S ARTICLE
Michel Colin-Deléger 2000 Saint-Aubin 1er Cru "En Charmois" ($28)
This is a clear, straw-color wine with a golden hue. Fresh appley aromas, the signature of Chardonnay, add an appealing rich note of roasted chestnuts and discreet oaky spice. Full, almost unctuous on the palate, apples are joined by hints of rising bread dough, luscious fruit on a firm acidic structure. A slightly awkward note of less-than-fully-integrated wood takes off a judging point or two, but doesn't really detract from the wine's overall appeal. U.S. importer: Kermit Lynch Wine Merchant, Berkeley, Calif. (Sept. 9, 2005)
FOOD MATCH: Fine with both courses of a meal fashioned to go with Chardonnay: Spaghetti tossed with butter and fresh sage, and shrimps sauteed in butter with garlic.
VALUE: Priced a bit above the everyday-enjoyment range, but you're not likely to find a Premier Cru white Burgundy for less. Bottom line, I'd buy another bottle or two at this price.
WHEN TO DRINK: White Burgundy cellars very well, and this one is showing little or no sign of age. I'd expect it to gain richness and complexity for at least a few more years under good cellar conditions. Note also that, although I purchased this wine recently at retail, it's several years behind the current vintage; the 2003 is already in the marketplace.
FIND THIS WINE ONLINE:
Kim Crawford 2003 Marlborough Unoaked Chardonnay ($12.99)
Glints of light brassy-green add a touch of color to this very pale, straw-color wine. It's pleasant and appealing but not at all what I expect in a Chardonnay: Citric lemons and limes and a back note of pears on the nose; crisp citric white fruit on the palate with a lean, rather tart structure. If I had confronted it without knowing the variety, I don't think I would have ever guessed Chardonnay, suggesting that the character most of us routinely associate with the grape variety may speak more than we realize of oak. U.S. importer: R. H. Phillips Inc., Esparto, Calif. (Sept. 7, 2005)
FOOD MATCH: Not bad with the butter-and-sage pasta and sauteed shrimps mentioned in the Deléger note, but its lean fruit-and-acid profile might have been better still with white, firm-fleshed fish.
VALUE: Assuming you like the style, then this low-teens price is a fine value for a dry, fruity white wine at this quality level.
WHEN TO DRINK: It's hard to predict an aging curve for an idiosyncratic style, but there's no reason not to drink it up young, while it's fresh and fruity.
FIND THIS WINE ONLINE:
Katrina fund-raiser: Last call for donations
Because contributions are still trickling in, I've decided to extend our informal wine-related fund-raiser for Hurricane Katrina victims another day or two, affording today's weekly-only subscribers one more opportunity to participate.
As I reported Friday, Wine Advisor readers and Wine Lovers' forum participants have responded with great generosity: A half-dozen of you offered additional gifts of fine wines to bolster the sweepstakes, and well over 100 readers have made contributions totaling more than $10,000 to non-profit organizations helping with hurricane relief.
Before Wednesday's edition, we'll randomly select winning numbers and notify the lucky participants who'll win such vinous goodies as a three-bottle "vertical" of mature Chateau Meyney, a 1999 J.L. Chave Hermitage, a 1982 Chateau Latour, a 1985 Chateau Lafite, and more.
If you haven't joined in this effort yet, I urge you to consider joining in, whether you're inspired by the possibility of winning an excellent wine or whether you simply feel that it's right to dig down and throw a few bucks into the hat to help the people who have suffered from this major natural disaster.
We're encouraging contributions through Network for Good, a reputable organization that acts as a clearinghouse for online contributions to quality nonprofit organizations in many areas of need. A list of more than 100 worthy Katrina-related organizations will be found online at
For full information on making your contribution and entering the sweepstakes, click to this Wine Lovers' Discussion Group forum announcement:
Enter to win California Wine Club's Newest Raffle: Monterey County's 9th Annual Great Wine Escape Weekend!
This event package, valued at $1,600, is for Nov. 10-13, 2005, and includes Thursday's Opening Gala, Friday's "Pairings at the Plaza", Saturday's winery open houses and a winemaker dinner, and Sunday's Grand Finale at the Inn at Spanish Bay, where more than 35 wineries will pour their finest selections. Additionally, The California Wine Club package also includes two nights accommodations at the luxurious Monterey Plaza Hotel & Spa. California is beautiful that time of year! Enter today at
This week on WineLoversPage.com
Here are links to some of our recently published articles that I think you'll enjoy:
Oxford Town Wines: No more boozy wines!
Wood on Wine: Fundamentals for Fun With Wine
QPRwines: 2001 Southern Rhône
Reports from our Readers: The Sunny Southern Rhone
Last Week's Wine Advisor Index
The Wine Advisor's daily edition is usually distributed on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays (and, for those who subscribe, the FoodLetter on Thursdays). Here's the index to last week's columns:
Falanghina encore (Sept. 9, 2005)
Lambrusco - It's better than you think (Sept. 7, 2005)
Sauvignon Blanc challenge (Sept. 5, 2005)
Complete 30 Second Wine Advisor archive:
Wine Advisor FoodLetter: Kung Pao chicken (Sept. 8, 2005)
Wine Advisor Foodletter archive:
To subscribe or unsubscribe from The 30 Second Wine Advisor, change your E-mail address, or for any other administrative matters, please use the individualized hotlink found at the end of your E-mail edition. If this is not practical, contact me by E-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org, including the exact E-mail address that you used when you subscribed, so I can find your record.
We do not use our E-mail list for any other purpose and will never give or sell your name or E-mail address to anyone. I welcome feedback, suggestions, and ideas for future columns. To contact me, please send E-mail to email@example.com
All the wine-tasting reports posted here are consumer-oriented. In order to maintain objectivity and avoid conflicts of interest, I purchase all the wines I rate at my own expense in retail stores and accept no samples, gifts or other gratuities from the wine industry.
Monday, Sept. 12, 2005