Supreme Court rules on wine shipping
States in the U.S. may not ban the shipment of wine directly to consumers if the state's laws permit in-state wineries to do so, the Supreme Court ruled in a closely split decision announced this morning. In short, everyone may ship or nobody may ship, but it's unconstitutional to grant preference to in-state shippers.
But wine lovers who live in states that do not now permit consumers to buy wine directly from out of state sources should not count on being able to jump online and start ordering wine.
Supporters of wine shipping were quick to declare the decision a great victory. The Institute for Justice, a Washington, D.C. group that had represented one of the plaintiffs in the two cases before the court, said the decision had "huge implications for interstate and electronic commerce." Institute attorney Clint Bolick added, "This is the best day for wine-lovers since the invention of the corkscrew. ... This opens up interstate markets just like our Founding Fathers envisioned. They wanted us to be one nation when it comes to trade - not 50 states. This is a boon for America's wine-loving consumers who like to have various wines from throughout the nation."
More measured voices in the wine-loving community, however, noted that little is likely to change for many Americans, particularly in the short term. The opinion addresses only the 24 states whose current laws permit in-state wineries to ship wine to consumers while forbidding out-of-state producers to do so. But many states do not permit shipping wine to consumers at all, and the court's ruling does not change that.
Justice Anthony Kennedy, who wrote the majority opinion, wrote, "States have broad power to regulate liquor ... This power, however, does not allow states to ban, or severely limit, the direct shipment of out-of-state wine while simultaneously authorizing direct shipment by in-state producers. If a state chooses to allow direct shipments of wine, it must do so on evenhanded terms."
This language makes it as easy for states to ban all direct-to-consumer sales - as New Jersey, for instance, did just last year rather than permit interstate shipping to its residents. It's safe to assume that the Wine and Spirits Wholesalers of America, the wealthy lobby group that represents distributors and that has led the battle against interstate shipping, will now turn its ample resources to fighting for overall shipping bans.
In addition to Justice Kennedy, Justices Antonin Scalia, David H. Souter, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen G. Breyer voted with the majority. In dissent were Chief Justice William Rehnquist and Justices John Paul Stevens, Sandra Day O'Connor and Clarence Thomas.
The decision focused only on wine shipping, but observers presume that its language clears the way for similar legislation governing beer and liquor shipment.
At the risk of saying "I told you so," I can't help but recall having written this analysis in the April 8 Wine Advisor: "Look for a ruling that states with laws like New York and Michigan must eliminate disparities between the laws governing shipping for in-state and out-of-state merchants ... a problem that those states could as easily resolve by denying all direct wine sales to consumers (as many states already do) as by permitting all such sales."
If legal language doesn't put you off, here's a link that bypasses media analysis and goes direct to primary sources: The Supreme Court's opinion on the shipping cases is already online here, in Adobe Acrobat (PDF) format:
PRINT OUT TODAY'S ARTICLE
TALK ABOUT WINE ONLINE
If you prefer to comment privately, feel free to send me E-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org. I'll respond personally to the extent that time and volume permit.
The world's best wine magazine
Since 1975 Decanter magazine has been the vital companion for wine lovers around the world. If you don't subscribe, this month you have missed:
US subscribers can enjoy 12 issues of Decanter delivered to their doorstep for just $49.99. Don't miss out again - subscribe today for great online savings.
PS Visit www.decanter.com to receive all the latest wine news delivered to your inbox every morning for free.
California Wine Club:
Forget the tie this year!
The California Wine Club is the ideal way to say "Happy Father's Day!" Featuring award-winning wines, hand-selected from California's best, boutique wineries.. This is a special gift that any Dad would love.
Each month your gift recipient will receive two bottles of extraordinary wine not found in local stores plus an entertaining 12-page magazine, Uncorked. Honor dad for more than just one day with a monthly membership from The California Wine Club for just $32.95 plus shipping. Take advantage of our Father's Day offer!
With a gift of six months or more we will include in his first shipment a bottle of wine from our upper-level club, The Signature Series. This month it is a fabulous Robert Rue Zinfandel. Just mention The 30 Second Wine Advisor and this offer when ordering. Call 1-800-777-4443 or visit
This week on WineLoversPage.com
Here are links to some of our recently published articles that I think you'll enjoy:
Dave McIntyre's WineLine: Good News from Chile
Wine Lovers' Voting Booth: How do you prepare for a wine tour?
Last Week's Wine Advisor Index
The Wine Advisor's daily edition is usually distributed on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays (and, for those who subscribe, the FoodLetter on Thursdays). Last week, however, we went on a vacation schedule because of my travels, skipping the usual Wednesday Wine Advisor and Thursday FoodLetter. Here's the index to last week's columns:
About Minervois (May 13, 2004)
Ptui! (May 11, 2004)
Wine travel tips (May 9, 2004)
Complete 30 Second Wine Advisor archive:
Wine Advisor FoodLetter: Bite-sized pepper steaks (May 12, 2004)
Wine Advisor Foodletter archive:
To subscribe or unsubscribe from The 30 Second Wine Advisor, change your E-mail address, or for any other administrative matters, please use the individualized hotlink found at the end of your E-mail edition. If this is not practical, contact me by E-mail at email@example.com, including the exact E-mail address that you used when you subscribed, so I can find your record.
We do not use our E-mail list for any other purpose and will never give or sell your name or E-mail address to anyone. I welcome feedback, suggestions, and ideas for future columns. To contact me, please send E-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org
All the wine-tasting reports posted here are consumer-oriented. In order to maintain objectivity and avoid conflicts of interest, I purchase all the wines I rate at my own expense in retail stores and accept no samples, gifts or other gratuities from the wine industry.
Monday, May 16, 2005