30 Second Wine Advisor
Today's sponsors
Penfolds Brings Red Wine Recorking Clinics to the United States

WineCommune: Discover the Best Place to Buy and Sell Fine Wine, On-Line

In This Issue
Oak or not?
Planeta 2001 "La Segreta" Sicilia Rosso ($10.99)

click here

For all past editions,
click here

For information, E-mail

Oak or not?

What's your take on oak in wine? Some wine lovers enjoy the spicy, aromatic elements that wines take on from being fermented and aged in oak barrels. Others argue that wine should be about fruit, not wood, and object to any treatment that alters that natural state.

For most of us, the truth - as usual - comes down somewhere between the two extremes. As I wrote in a 30 Second Wine Advisor article a few years ago, the abuse and overuse of oak in wine is something to rant about. From California Chardonnay to Barossa Shiraz, wines that taste more of wood than fruit rarely make me smile; and when oak aromas reach the point at which a wine reminds me of the smell of freshly sanded oak floors, I tend to put down the glass and look for something else to drink.

If you're interested in making a more detailed study of this topic, we're taking on "Detecting Oak" as the theme of this month's feature in our ongoing Wine Tasting 101 project http://www.wineloverspage.com/forum/wt101.phtml. I've selected a pair of Chardonnays from a Washington State winery, Columbia Crest, that I believe will provide a good comparison between oaky and not-oaky characteristics, and also propose a short list of a few other wines chosen to display the use (or non-use) of oak in wine. You're invited to click the link above for more information about participating in this free, informal project.

Let's finish up today with a quick summary of that January 2001 article, which I'll follow with a tasting report on a fairly oaky Sicilian red.

It's worth mentioning that oak is not necessarily a bad thing. Many, perhaps most, fine wines spend some time in oak casks during the winemaking process. Wooden barrels were used in wine making for centuries before stainless steel tanks were feasible; visit the greatest chateaus of Bordeaux and the finest caves of Burgundy and you'll see rows of oak barrels in which great wines are gently aging.

From Chianti to Rioja and around the world, fine and ageworthy red wines without oak would be unthinkable, and wine makers spend a great deal of time contemplating oak and how to use it. Small barrels and new wood impart more oak flavor and tannins to the wine than larger wooden tanks or older wood; toasting barrels over fire creates a different flavor than untreated oak. New barrels import more and stronger flavors than used cooperage. American oak, Slavonian oak from Croatia, many different kinds of French oak ... just as grapes vary by variety, regional oaks contribute different aromas and flavors to the wine.

So where do wine makers go wrong? In my opinion, trouble comes when wood fights fruit and wood wins. A wine that smacks more of vanilla, coconut or freshly sawed planks - the signature scents of heavy to excessive oak - seems to me to miss the mark.

Why do they do it, then? In the case of some modest wines, it may simply reflect an effort to compensate for mediocre grapes. But it's clear that some consumers - including some of the most influential critics - enjoy the taste of oak. A rave from a powerful wine writer can be money in the bank for a wine maker.

But I like the pithy advice once rendered by Richard Eccleston, a well-known Boston-area wine retailer: "Oak is a spice, not a sauce."

For another short discussion of oak in wine, see my January 2000 article, "Wood or fruit? The role of oak in wine,"

La Segreta Planeta 2001 "La Segreta" Sicilia Rosso ($10.99)

This modern Sicilian red offers a blend of the old (60 percent Nero d'Avola grapes) and the new (20 percent each Merlot and Syrah). Inky dark ruby in color, it shows reddish-purple glints against the light. Plummy, pruney scents add spicy, aromatic overtones of new oak, showing more wood than the technical notes would suggest (it spends just three months in two-year-old barrels after fermentation in stainless steel). Its ripe and juicy black-fruit flavor is shaped by plenty of fresh-fruit acidity for balance. Very much in the "international" style, its big and wood-tinged fruit reminds me somewhat of an Australian Shiraz. U.S. importer: VIAS Imports Ltd., NYC. (April 9, 2003)

FOOD MATCH: Good flavor combination but a little on the robust side to make a perfect match with my choice, chicken braised with garlic and fennel. I'll try it next time with grilled beef or lamb.

VALUE: Good value at this price if you like the style.

WHEN TO DRINK: Ready to go, but there's no need to hurry; it will last and might even improve over the next few years.

WINERY WEBSITE: La Planeta has a comprehensive Website in Italian and English at
Note that the Website requires the "Flash" plug-in and is best viewed with a high-speed connection.

Follow-up: Website for Elyse

In Wednesday's Wine Advisor, I mentioned having been unable to locate a Website for Elyse, the California producer of the 1999 D l'Aventure Rhone-style red featured in the day's tasting report.

Thanks to several of you for pointing out the obvious: Elyse is indeed online, at

This is also a Flash introduction, but you may be able to bypass it if you prefer by clicking directly to the first content page,


To subscribe or unsubscribe from The 30 Second Wine Advisor, change your E-mail address, or for any other administrative matters, please use the individualized hotlink found at the end of your E-mail edition. If this is not practical, contact me by E-mail at wine@wineloverspage.com, including the exact E-mail address that you used when you subscribed, so I can find your record.

We do not use our E-mail list for any other purpose and will never give or sell your name or E-mail address to anyone. I welcome feedback, suggestions, and ideas for future columns. To contact me, please send E-mail to wine@wineloverspage.com

All the wine-tasting reports posted here are consumer-oriented. In order to maintain objectivity and avoid conflicts of interest, I purchase all the wines I rate at my own expense in retail stores and accept no samples, gifts or other gratuities from the wine industry.

Wednesday, April 30, 2003
Copyright 2002 by Robin Garr. All rights reserved.

Subscribe to the 30 Second Wine Advisor

Wine Advisor archives