Syrahs from two different worlds
A similar division appears among wine lovers, many of whom take careful notice of the differences and similarities between "Old World" wines made in France, Italy, Germany and the other nations of Europe, and "New World" wines - many of them affectionately made in styles rooted in the European tradition - from the rest of the world.
This became particularly clear to me during my recent travels in Australia, where Shiraz (identical to the grape that France and the U.S. call "Syrah") is perhaps the leading wine grape. Most of Australia's wineries produce a style of Shiraz that's distinctly regional in character - big, peppery, fruity and oaky. I reported on dozens of these in my extensive Down Under Wine Diary, http://www.wineloverspage.com/wines/ozdiary.shtml.
They're typically impressive wines in a tooth-staining, head-spinning "blockbuster" style that takes some getting used to and doesn't always make them natural partners with food, but critical raves from around the world (and especially in the U.S.) have created a demand that has made many of them highly sought-after - and far more expensive outside Australia than when they're sold at the "cellar door."
At the same time, they are utterly different in nature from the Syrah-based wines of the French Rhone region, which are also wines that I love. Rhone reds are rarely as big and overpowering as Australian Shirazes. Where Oz offers fat fruit and sweet oak, France counters with balance and complexity, adding "organic" and "earthy" elements that may remind the taster of forest floors, mushrooms, leather, even "grilled meat" and "barnyard" aromas and flavors that might send an Australian (or a Californian) running for the exit.
I wouldn't necessarily argue that either approach is "better." But they're decidedly different, and each style certainly has its partisans.
To recalibrate my palate for France and California after my month Down Under, I set up a recent "blind" tasting between a French and a California Syrah of similar vintage and roughly similar price. The results are posted below and on Wine Lovers' Page (with label images) at http://www.wineloverspage.com/wines/wt121500.shtml.
What's your opinion? Do you find a consistent difference between Old World and New World wine styles? Do you have a particular preference or find one style much preferable to the other? Or, like me, is there room in your wine world for both? If you would like to talk about it in more detail, please feel free to join in the chat on our Wine Lovers' Discussion Group, or send me a note by E-mail to email@example.com. I regret that the growing circulation of the "Wine Advisor" makes it difficult for me to reply individually to every note, and my travels this month will also limit my ability to respond; but I'll answer as many as I can; and please be assured that all your input helps me do a better job of writing about wine.
We hope you'll invite your wine-loving friends to register for their own free weekly copy at http://www.wineloverspage.com/wineadvisor.
Old World and New World Syrahs
Wines World (Norway)
Winetasting.com is an online cooperative of Californiaís leading wineries selling directly to wine lovers. This gives customers like you unique access to limited-release wines not available outside the tasting room. For full information, visit http://www.winetasting.com/hub/landing.asp?wlpgid=WLPG001LA. I have known these folks for a long time and can confidently recommend them.
You are on the subscription list because you registered during a visit to Robin Garr's Wine Lovers' Page. If for any reason you no longer want to receive this publication, simply send a short E-mail to 'firstname.lastname@example.org' asking to be unsubscribed (and, if you wish, offering us any suggestions you may have as to how we could have served you better), and we'll remove your name from the list. We do not use this list for any other purpose and will never give or sell your name or E-mail to anyone.
If your E-mail program is having trouble handling the images in this edition, feel free to request that we switch you from the HTML to TEXT edition ... or vice versa. Please contact us in the same way if your E-mail address changes. And of course we welcome feedback, suggestions, and ideas for future columns. Send us E-mail at email@example.com.
All the wine-tasting reports posted here are consumer-oriented. In order to maintain objectivity and avoid conflicts of interest, I purchase all the wines I rate at my own expense in retail stores and accept no samples, gifts or other gratuities from the wine industry.
If you'd like to talk about wine online with fellow wine enthusiasts around the world, we'd be delighted to have you join the interactive, international forums in our Wine Lovers' Discussion Group.
Vol. 2, No. 48, Dec. 18, 2000