Manuel Camblor wrote:Ah, okay... So the somelier person was at the mercy of the guests in terms of what he sampled or didn't. That explains a lot.
Manuel Camblor wrote:"Planets"? Don't you think that's being a bit unkind to the point-givers and their girth?
Bernard Roth wrote:I actually think the idea of scoring wines fuzzes too much to really differentiate a 98 pointer from a 100 pointer. For example, the 95 Baumard QdC got a 98 point rating, which I concur about. Yet I consider it to be a perfect QdC. The 2001 Yquem is a more magnificent wine than the QdC, so even though both are perfect for their genres, I think it still makes sense to allocate extra points for magnificence beyond what is earned for mere perfection.
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 7 guests