Bill, I agree with your notes straight down the line. But of course, some extra comments.
Re the Reynvaan, I'm so glad you enjoyed it. I brought it to show the group, of course, but I mostly had you in mind because I know you've made some forays into WA syrah with Bunnell and a few others, and I think this shows WA's potential on a whole 'nother level. although there aren't enough vintages behind us to know what 'typical' is, and it's possible that between not-neccessarily reliable younger vines and the evolving relationship between winemaker (same as Cayuse, Christophe Baron) and the Reynvaan family who are running things hands-on, not to mention the fact that all three commercial vintages thus far*, I'm guessing that the 09 In The Rocks is pretty atypical in being so generously open right now (an Unnamed did not similarly reward me) without a bunch of baby fat. And I'm actually pretty glad about it--it's certainly why I risked opening a bottle so young at a Gav lunch! Too, it has served to re-affirm my commitment to vintages 10 and 12. Between on-hand and futures, I have about three cases. Oh, and I've ordered the '12 cabernet, too.
Re the Tempier blanc, it never makes it into our market either. Kermit Lynch only got 50 cases and most of it stayed in NY, though somehow the restaurauteur I convinced to sell me this one got a whole case. It's the only bottle I've ever seen.
Re the Boudreaux, I didn't care for it either, and was shocked by how that showed. A few years ago it was a model of restraint and cool-vintage dynamics. Now? Blowsy and almost vulgar. Kind of like Shelly Winters at two different stages of her career.
And the Turley: I hope you don't have many more, they're fairly hard to drink! And what a bitch to store those bottles. I opened my last just two weeks ago, inspired because I was looking through bottles of zin for some other occasion. Merely touching the bottle as I attempted to move it aside caused an avalanche out of the bin it was kept in, and that wasn't the first time. I took that as a sign that it wanted to leave so I took TWO zins to that occasion (a Ridge Pagani Ranch to stave off questions about my sanity). I don't think I've ever been happier to see a bottle go away!
*08, 09 and 10 which I know of and own, and I'm already in for 12's which haven't been released yet; never saw an 11 and I wonder if in fact they made any 11--it was so bad a vintage in this state that the Reynvaans might have opted out rather than dilute impressions re Reynvaan quality, a wise move if one has big aspirations and can afford it