WTN: 2003 Robert Craig "Howell Mountain" CS

From near the peak of the Howell Mountain District overlooking St. Helena (2,300 feet!). Stored somewhat warm, but no signs of premature aging. Dark ruby cab color with clear ruby rim. Nose is quite nice: clove, anise, black plum, which follows through on the palate as well. Very smooth...the mountain tannins appear to have softened substantially and this cab is fully open for business. Quite nice plum and earth and anise flavors with a fine finish. Quite pleasant...not as exciting as a couple of the other wines we've had lately, but still a solid 89 points. Others at the table rated it higher, so what do I know?

I've known Bob Craig for many years, good guy. 03 here in the valley is known as a mediocre vintage at best. Bob's wine's as a group are solid and not overpriced as a rule.

We're also fans of the Robert Craig wines. They're a little pricey for us, but they tend to show well against more expensive Napa cabs in our experience. Haven't had the '03 Howell, though.

I've enjoyed tasting at Craig in their little off the beaten track tasting room near downtown Napa.

As to 2003 being a mediocre vintage....Is this another case of 1998? Sure, there are some bad 1998s, but the best winemakers made superb wines, imho. They have aged better than the 1997s, to my limited experience? 2000 was another "mediocre" vintage, and I've had some good ones! I guess I have a fond spot for the vintage because they were just coming out a few years ago when I was just starting to obsess about wine! And, I think some of the 2003s are opening up pretty nicely right now.

Not sure I believe the vintage proclamations anymore. Remember that all the usual sources declared 2003 France to be phenomenal. Do we agree now?