Voting Booth Archives 2004


Dec. 27, 2004

Total Votes: 1053

Wine buying strategy for 2005
No real change 57 (5%)
Buy more wine 140 (13%)
Buy less wine 68 (6%)
Stay with the familiar 36 (3%)
Branch out and experiment 196 (18%)
Buy more expensive wine 99 (9%)
Buy more affordable wine 104 (9%)
Buy more online/mail order 47 (4%)
Buy more locally 62 (5%)
Try a wine-of-the-month club 15 (1%)
Get on more winery mailing lists 49 (4%)
Get off the mailing lists 10 (0%)
Explore high-end "cult" wines 23 (2%)
Start following Parker 17 (1%)
Cancel Parker subscription 15 (1%)
Start following Wine Spectator 23 (2%)
Cancel Wine Spectator subscription 34 (3%)
Other (fill-in) 58 (5%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • A year of drinking and cellar emptying (1 votes)
  • At least 10 grapes I haven't had (1 votes)
  • Avoid Wine Spectator and all other "gurus" (1 votes)
  • Baby on the way, new priorities! (1 votes)
  • but more US wines from Ohio ,Virginia and other non-typical regions (1 votes)
  • Buy based on actuary tables-not vintage charts (1 votes)
  • Buy better wine (1 votes)
  • buy better wines, at whatever price point (1 votes)
  • Buy for the (new) cellar (1 votes)
  • buy less that need cellar time (1 votes)
  • Buy more 2002 South Australian Reds (1 votes)
  • buy more vintage port, rioja, and barolo (1 votes)
  • Buy more wine from TN's (1 votes)
  • Buy more young wine (1 votes)
  • Buy wines for 101 and expand knowledge, (1 votes)
  • Buy with an eye on wine education. (1 votes)
  • Cancel 1-2 wine club membeships (1 votes)
  • Clear out the bottom of my cellar (1 votes)
  • Continue following Wine Spectator (1 votes)
  • Continue to buy high quality high price/perfromance-ratio wines (1 votes)
  • corner the market on 2001 Napa Cabs (1 votes)
  • deepen knowledge of certain regions (1 votes)
  • Do more reading, focus on particular region (Piedmont) (1 votes)
  • Drink More (1 votes)
  • Drink more French and Italian wines (1 votes)
  • Drink what I have! (1 votes)
  • Expand my wine "cellar" (i.e. lay more down!) (1 votes)
  • Find a good cheap 'house wine' and stick with it, splurging occasionally (1 votes)
  • Focus on French wines (1 votes)
  • Follow Wine Enthusiast Mag (1 votes)
  • Give up on all pinot noirs. I just don't like them. (1 votes)
  • half the fun is learning, and I never want to stop learning! (1 votes)
  • Hope the SAQ strike ends soon (1 votes)
  • host some wine tasting get togethers at home (1 votes)
  • IGNORE WINE SPECTATOR ADVICE (1 votes)
  • internet research (1 votes)
  • learn more about wine (1 votes)
  • Less beer, more wine (1 votes)
  • Make more wine (2 votes)
  • More Burgundy, Rioja, and odd DOC/G Italians (1 votes)
  • more case purchases, less onsey-twosey purchases (1 votes)
  • only buy wines with a high QPR (1 votes)
  • purchase favorites in larger quanitites--four to six bottles at a time instead of one to three bottl (1 votes)
  • Rad innovation: smart buying. Stick to fav appels, try an armful of singles, buy vol only of best. (1 votes)
  • Read more on-line wine resources (e.g. blogs) (1 votes)
  • Refine past buying strategy concentrating on the wines I really want to age (1 votes)
  • Replenish the cellar (1 votes)
  • Restock some hard to find vintners I like/ drink less yet better (1 votes)
  • Sit back, uncork, pour and enjoy, with or without a fine meal. (1 votes)
  • Stay away from over-priced, over-rated Bordeaux and Burgundy! (1 votes)
  • Subscribe to Decanter (1 votes)
  • taste more with friends (1 votes)
  • try more wines that a local honest retailer recommends (1 votes)
  • Try to acquire the hybrid & labrusca wines that I meant to this year but never got around to. (1 votes)
  • Try to avoid bankrupting myself as the declining dollar makes my favorite wines more expensive. (1 votes)
  • visit more wineries (1 votes)
  • Visit more wineries. (1 votes)


Dec. 6, 2004

Total Votes: 561

Buying wine online
Legal here, and I do it 202 (36%)
Legal here, but I don't 45 (8%)
Not legal here, but I do it anyway 141 (25%)
Not legal here, and I don't 173 (30%)


Nov. 22, 2004

Total Votes: 307

My usual wine-shop purchase ...
1 bottle 15 (4%)
2 or 3 bottles 114 (37%)
4 or 5 bottles 54 (17%)
6-bottle case 16 (5%)
7 to 11 bottles 17 (5%)
12-bottle case 59 (19%)
More than 1 case 27 (8%)
I buy only online/mail order 5 (1%)


Nov. 8, 2004

Total Votes: 424

Political preference?
Republican 103 (24%)
Democrat 137 (32%)
Independent 56 (13%)
Liberal 52 (12%)
Conservative 28 (6%)
Other (Fill-in) 48 (11%)
Here are the fill-in votes:

  • A little to the right of Genghis Khan (1 votes)
  • Anyone running against GWB Party (1 votes)
  • Apolitical (2 votes)
  • Can't find a box-fits-all - assess issue/personality on merits (1 votes)
  • Canadian! (1 votes)
  • Caring conservative (1 votes)
  • Constitution Party (1 votes)
  • democratic socialist/green (1 votes)
  • Donald Duck (1 votes)
  • Druid (1 votes)
  • Fiscal conservative / social liberal (1 votes)
  • Fiscal conservative, civil libertarian (small l ! ) (1 votes)
  • fiscally conservative; socially moderate (1 votes)
  • green (2 votes)
  • greenish caring libertarian (1 votes)
  • Liberal Democrat (1 votes)
  • liberal on social issues, conservative on fiscal issues (1 votes)
  • libertarian (9 votes)
  • libertarian (Yes, with a little 'l') (1 votes)
  • Libertarian -- Not quite the same as Liberal as Libertarian is an actual party! (1 votes)
  • no party - liberal preferences (1 votes)
  • Oenophile (1 votes)
  • pessimistic radical (1 votes)
  • Progressive left (1 votes)
  • radical feminist (1 votes)
  • Radical left (1 votes)
  • Republicrat (1 votes)
  • Social Democrat (1 votes)
  • Social liberal (borderline libertarian), economic conservative (NOT neocon) (1 votes)
  • Social Liberal, Fiscal Conservative (1 votes)
  • Socialist (3 votes)
  • Socially conservative but dislike "economic Darwinism" (1 votes)
  • Usually end up picking the lesser of two evils (1 votes)
  • Way left of anything acceptable in US (1 votes)
  • Whomever I think will do the most for the country! (1 votes)
  • _A Vote Against W (1 votes)


Oct. 4, 2004

Total Votes: 911

How much is too much?
None 3 (0%)
One drink per day 17 (1%)
Two drinks 60 (6%)
Three drinks 239 (26%)
Four drinks 280 (30%)
One bottle 160 (17%)
More than 1 bottle 152 (16%)


Sept. 6, 2004

Total Votes: 436

Organize the wine shop
Country/region 230 (52%)
Grape variety 97 (22%)
Wine style 65 (14%)
Price 7 (1%)
Alphabetical 3 (0%)
Doesn't matter, just give me helpful staff 27 (6%)
Other (fill-in) 7 (1%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • By grape variety within each country (1 votes)
  • by the length of the name of the wine (1 votes)
  • Country/Region, then grape variety (1 votes)
  • First by wine style, then by country/region, then alphabetically. (1 votes)
  • Grape variety by price (1 votes)
  • Intuitive Use Catagories (1 votes)
  • virgina wines in blue bottles (1 votes)

Aug. 2, 2004

Total Votes: 510

The wine closure of the future?
Artificial corks in less than 10 years 57 (11%)
Artificial corks in 10 years or more 10 (1%)
Screwcaps in less than 10 years 267 (52%)
Screwcaps in 10 years or more 46 (9%)
Crown caps in less than 10 years 6 (1%)
Natural cork will remain dominant 76 (14%)
I don't know 6 (1%)
I don't care 10 (1%)
Other (fill-in) 32 (6%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • (CORRECTION)Only when masturbation replaces coitus will unnaturalcorks be acceptable to wine lover. (1 votes)
  • artificial scotch bottle knob cork (1 votes)
  • Caps, plasti-corks for cheap and popular, -5 yrs. Corks for most artisanal wines, foreseeable future (2 votes)
  • Combination of artificial corks and screwcaps in less than 10 years (1 votes)
  • Cork, real or artificial, forever!!! (1 votes)
  • glass corks in the future (1 votes)
  • I believe the 'natural cork' has a romance about it that can never be replaced. It's the ritual. (1 votes)
  • I like tradition! (1 votes)
  • I was in favor of screwcaps, but wary since I got no screwcaps on the screw-died bottle. . (1 votes)
  • mix of screwcaps and artificial corks in less than 10 years (1 votes)
  • natural cork will fade and resurge in about 10 to 15 years (1 votes)
  • Natural corks for wines that really matter, (1 votes)
  • natural corks in the best wines, crowns in everything else (1 votes)
  • No more "Do you have a corkscrew! Yeah!!!!! (1 votes)
  • Only when masturbation replaces coitus will unnaturalcorks be acceptable to wine lovers. (1 votes)
  • Only when masturbation replaces coitus wilnatural corks be acceptable to a wine lover. (1 votes)
  • Screw caps will take all the romance out of opening a bottle of wine! (1 votes)
  • screwcap: wines meant to be consumed young; cork: traditional estates on select curvees (1 votes)
  • Screwcaps and artificial corks to dominate in less than 10 years (1 votes)
  • screwcaps and glass closures (1 votes)
  • screwcaps for whites and natural cork for reds (1 votes)
  • Screwcaps in less than 10 years because of $$$$$$'s - booooo (1 votes)
  • Screwcaps in less than 10 years IF down the line no problems are encountered. (1 votes)
  • screwcaps in less than 10 yrs. for majority of wines, but cork will prove best for long term aging (1 votes)
  • screwcaps on youthful wines within 10 years, cork in "ageworthy wine" (1 votes)
  • screwcaps w/in 2 years (1 votes)
  • The Stelvin Cap will quadruple the number of wines openned in American households in less than five. (1 votes)
  • There will be a better alternative to screwcaps in less than 10 years (1 votes)
  • Vino-Lok in less than 10 years (1 votes)
  • Whites in screw caps in ten, reds longer (1 votes)
  • Wine will be avilable in sealed baggies similar as todays fruit juices. It's called cost savings. (1 votes)


July 14, 2004

Total Votes: 587

Best wine match with grilled fare
Zinfandel 166 (28%)
Syrah, Shiraz or Petite Sirah 127 (21%)
Red Rhone blends 68 (11%)
Merlot 20 (3%)
Cabernet Sauvignon and Bordeaux blends 78 (13%)
Sangiovese and Chianti blends 29 (4%)
Gewurztraminer 3 (0%)
White ... any white 5 (0%)
Dry Rosé 16 (2%)
White Zinfandel 2 (0%)
Cheap bubbly 1 (0%)
Beer, of course! 21 (3%)
Unsweet iced tea 1 (0%)
Other (fill-in) 50 (8%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • 7 Deadly Zins!!!!!!! (1 votes)
  • anything red (1 votes)
  • barbaresco (1 votes)
  • barbera (1 votes)
  • barolo (1 votes)
  • Barolo and Barbaresco (1 votes)
  • Cab Franc - Yakima Valley (1 votes)
  • Cabernet Franc (single varietal or minimum amt. of cab sauv/merlot) (1 votes)
  • carmenere (1 votes)
  • Chardonnay (1 votes)
  • Corsican reds (1 votes)
  • Cru Beaujolais (1 votes)
  • depends upon the grilled item/style (1 votes)
  • diet coke (1 votes)
  • Eaton Hill Winery 2002 Cox Canyon Vineyards Cabernet Franc (1 votes)
  • Estancia Pinot Noir (1 votes)
  • Gigondas (1 votes)
  • Grenache from Spain (1 votes)
  • Grilled steak or grilled fish? (1 votes)
  • light, not-too-fruity Cabernet varietals from around the world (1 votes)
  • Madiran or other Tannat-based wine (1 votes)
  • Malbec (3 votes)
  • Malbec (Oregon or South American) (1 votes)
  • Nice cool served Tarrango, Brown Brothes Australia (1 votes)
  • norton (1 votes)
  • Old-school Pinotage or a smoky Foch. (1 votes)
  • Oregon Pinot Noir (1 votes)
  • pinot blanc (1 votes)
  • Pinot Noir (5 votes)
  • pinot noir -- delicious with a smoked pork butt (1 votes)
  • Pinot noirs, of course (1 votes)
  • Pinotage (2 votes)
  • Rosemont GSM (1 votes)
  • Roussillon and Languedoc wines (based on syrah, grenache, mourvedre,carignan and/or cinsault) (1 votes)
  • Sauvignon Blanc (1 votes)
  • Sauvignon Blanc (for grilled veggies) (1 votes)
  • Spanish red from Rioja (2 votes)
  • Sweet Southern Muscadine (1 votes)
  • Tempranillo (1 votes)
  • Tempranillo, Rioja (1 votes)
  • teran (terrano) (1 votes)
  • White Rhone blends - something with a little weight, but still crisp and cold (1 votes)


June 28, 2004

Total Votes: 207

Buy it, drink it, or wait?
Today or tomorrow 16 (7%)
Within one week 21 (10%)
Within one month 35 (16%)
Within three months 32 (15%)
Within one year 48 (23%)
Longer than one year 55 (26%)


June 7, 2004

Total Votes: 155

How long should wine rest after shipping?
What - I should wait? 10 (6%)
A day or three 11 (7%)
About a week 37 (23%)
About two weeks 31 (20%)
About a month 24 (15%)
Depends on age of the wine 8 (5%)
Depends on whether it's filtered 2 (1%)
Depends on the specific wine 18 (11%)
Depends on how far it traveled 5 (3%)
Other (fill-in) 9 (5%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • About two weeks for the wines made in my favorite producing country, which are mostly white. (1 votes)
  • As Dionysis as my witness, drain that bottle the on the day of delivery (1 votes)
  • Assuming I only brought it home from the winery, I don't see a need to let it rest. (1 votes)
  • At least six weeks. Six months for older bottles with substantial sediment. (1 votes)
  • Depends on type of wine, age, how far the wine has traveled, how the wine was transported, etc. (1 votes)
  • Depends upon all the last 5 variables, plus the travelling conditions (i.e. temp, agitation, etc) (1 votes)
  • Long experience importing from France to Australia taught me that 3 months is needed (1 votes)
  • Only to let sediment, if any, settle. (1 votes)
  • Usually two or three months (1 votes)


May 17, 2004

Total Votes: 1615

I feel justified in returning a wine when ...
"Corked" 285 (17%)
Oxidized 229 (14%)
Heat-damaged 238 (14%)
Seepage in the capsule 129 (7%)
Label damaged 10 (0%)
Label missing 74 (4%)
Wine is not clear 57 (3%)
Wine is cloudy 83 (5%)
Wine is discolored 95 (5%)
Excessive sediment 32 (1%)
Overpriced for quality 5 (0%)
Wasn't what I expected 7 (0%)
Bad match with food 2 (0%)
"Just doesn't taste right" 65 (4%)
For replacement only, not refund 103 (6%)
Only with recent purchases 126 (7%)
Any purchase, no matter how long ago 38 (2%)
Never 10 (0%)
Other (fill-in) 27 (1%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • Wine Incorrectly Identified by Seller or wrong AP no. (1 votes)
  • any spoilage-ethyl acetate-geranium nose-spoilage yeast-excess acetic acid (1 votes)
  • bottle damage (1 votes)
  • Bought on recommendation of a "clerk" that knows my tastes, but misses on this rec (1 votes)
  • Brett, VA, re-fermentation (1 votes)
  • excessive volatile acidity (1 votes)
  • I have never returned wine (1 votes)
  • I have not had to return a bottle so far. (1 votes)
  • If a recommended/up-sold wine is not as represented (1 votes)
  • If the merchant misrepresented the quality/taste of wine and convinced you to purchase more expensiv (1 votes)
  • insect, debris or ball bearing present (1 votes)
  • more than $20 (1 votes)
  • Not posible in my country (1 votes)
  • One is never justified in returning wine. What a boorish question! (1 votes)
  • only for $30+ bottles that have been damaged (corked, seepage etc) (1 votes)
  • over-oaked (1 votes)
  • plastic closure imitating cork (1 votes)
  • Refermentation (1 votes)
  • salesperson exagerated quality of the wine (1 votes)
  • secondary fermentation (1 votes)
  • when have plastic stopper (1 votes)
  • When merchant describes it's taste incorrectly (1 votes)
  • When they substitute vintage not ordered (1 votes)
  • Will return a restaurant bottle if 'bad' but not if I chose poorly. (1 votes)
  • wine is muddy and/or "dead" tasting (1 votes)
  • within three years (1 votes)
  • You are never justified in returning a wine. What a completely boorish notion! (1 votes)


April 19, 2004

Total Votes: 4373

Wines I haven't tried yet
I have tried them all 7 (0%)
I have tasted none of them 15 (0%)
Aglianico 177 (4%)
Albariño 126 (2%)
Arneis 176 (4%)
Barbera 43 (0%)
Chambourcin 200 (4%)
Dolcetto 76 (1%)
Fiano di Avellino 212 (4%)
Freisa 225 (5%)
Greco di Tufo 180 (4%)
Gruner Veltliner 116 (2%)
Lemberger/Blaufränkisch 171 (3%)
Malvasia 128 (2%)
Mataro/Mourvèdre/Monastrell 62 (1%)
Mondeuse 229 (5%)
Nero d'Avola 140 (3%)
Pineau d'Aunis 237 (5%)
Pinotage 89 (2%)
Poulsard 245 (5%)
Scheurebe 189 (4%)
Tannat 179 (4%)
Tempranillo 33 (0%)
Tocai Friulano 145 (3%)
Torrontes 196 (4%)
Verdelho 113 (2%)
Verduzzo 225 (5%)
Vermentino 179 (4%)
Vignoles 193 (4%)
Viognier 45 (1%)
Other (fill-in) 22 (0%)

Here are the fill-in votes:

  • Amarone (1 votes)
  • anything Georgian (1 votes)
  • Baco Noir (1 votes)
  • Barolo (1 votes)
  • bornada (1 votes)
  • Carbono/Carbona/Charbono (1 votes)
  • Chateau-Chalon (1 votes)
  • Gamay (haven't tried a Beaujolais yet) (1 votes)
  • Greek varieties (1 votes)
  • Hungarian tokaj (1 votes)
  • malbec (1 votes)
  • Malbec, Carmenere (1 votes)
  • Mencia (1 votes)
  • Most hybrids (1 votes)
  • Norton (1 votes)
  • NORTON!!! (1 votes)
  • rkatsiteli (1 votes)
  • Ruche, Pelaverga di Verduno, Pinot Meunier (as single varietal), Zweigelt, St. Laurent (1 votes)
  • Tamaiosa Romanesca (1 votes)
  • Tarrango, Greek verieties (1 votes)
  • tokaki aszu essensia, ch. d'quem (1 votes)
  • traminette+ a host of Greek, Turkish and Georgian varieties (1 votes)


March 19, 2004

Total Votes: 600

Do shelf 'talkers' influence your wine purchase?
Greatly 109 (18%)
Somewhat 290 (48%)
Only a little 156 (26%)
Not at all 45 (7%)


March 1, 2004

Total Votes: 300

I drink wine with food ...
Rarely or never 13 (4%)
About 25% of the time 23 (7%)
About 50% of the time 63 (21%)
About 75% of the time 77 (25%)
Just about always 124 (41%)


Feb. 9, 2004

Total Votes: 694

Worst wine advice
All this wine needs is a little cellar time. 31 (4%)
All that alcohol is good: it preserves the wine. 19 (2%)
Out of balance? Just wait a few years. 21 (3%)
If a little oak is good, more is better. 83 (11%)
There's never a bad vintage in California. 42 (6%)
This vintage wasn't that bad. 14 (2%)
It's supposed to smell like that. 76 (10%)
New World wines won't age. Buy Old World only. 17 (2%)
Old World wines reek. Buy New World only. 11 (1%)
Eastern U.S. states don't make good wine. 26 (3%)
French-hybrid grapes are just as good as vinifera. 7 (1%)
You'll love this Chardonnay ... it's buttery. 53 (7%)
If you like Chateau Rolex, you'll love this Chateau. 10 (1%)
This wine will be a great investment. 34 (4%)
Parker rated it 99. You'll love it. 52 (7%)
The Spectator loved it. So will you. 69 (9%)
Hate the wine? Then cook with it. 67 (9%)
You should buy a wine cellar. 9 (1%)
You should get into the wine business. 53 (7%)


Jan. 12, 2004

Total Votes: 497

What's your wine-list strategy?
Splurge on the best 5 (1%)
Fancier than I drink at home 58 (11%)
About the same as I drink at home 123 (24%)
Save with a cheaper wine 47 (9%)
Seek best value regardless of price 187 (37%)
Only the cheapest on the list 2 (0%)
Who can afford restaurant wine? 40 (8%)
Only by the glass 35 (7%)


Voting Booth Archives 2005

Voting Booth Archives 2003

Voting Booth Archives 2002

Voting Booth Archives 2001/2000

Earlier Voting Booth Archives

Wine Lovers' Voting Booth

 

All contents © copyright 1981-2008 by Robin Garr, www.WineLoversPage.com

Cliffwood Organic Works